Zero Reports Doesn't Mean There's Nothing Wrong
Why boards and executives need to look beyond whistleblower reporting volumes to understand whether their people really feel safe speaking up.
CORE INTEGRITY INSIGHTS / NOVEMBER 2026
Why boards and executives need to look beyond whistleblower reporting volumes to understand whether their people really feel safe speaking up.
By Darren Murphy | CEO & Founder, Core Integrity
When a board or executive report shows zero whistleblower disclosures for the quarter, it's tempting to see that as good news.
No complaints. No misconduct. Nothing to worry about.
But after more than 25 years working in investigations, integrity and whistleblowing, I've learnt that the absence of reports doesn't mean the absence of problems.
In fact, sometimes it means the exact opposite.
Zero reports might indicate an organisation has a healthy culture, where concerns are being addressed early through managers, People & Culture and other internal channels.
But it could just as easily mean employees don't know where to go, don't feel safe raising concerns, or simply don't trust that anything will change if they do.
And that's where I think many organisations are asking the wrong question.
Rather than asking why they're receiving complaints, perhaps they should be asking why they're not hearing about them.
What the numbers actually tell us
In December 2025, ASIC released Report 827, Insights from the ASIC Whistleblower Questionnaire, examining the whistleblower practices of 134 Australian companies.
One finding stood out to me.
22% of the companies surveyed received zero whistleblower disclosures during the reporting period.
That's almost one in four organisations.
Interestingly, 13 of the 30 companies reporting zero disclosures employed at least 1,000 people.
Now, ASIC doesn't tell us precisely why those organisations received no disclosures. And I'm certainly not suggesting that every organisation recording zero reports has a problem.
But I do think it raises some important questions.
ASIC also found that organisations with more mature whistleblower practices generally received higher disclosure rates. Those with dedicated reporting channels, regular training and ongoing communication tended to hear more from their people.
That should give boards and executives something to think about.
It's also worth considering the international picture.
NAVEX's 2026 Whistleblowing & Incident Management Benchmark Report recorded a global median of 1.65 reports per 100 employees, compared with ASIC's Australian median of 0.22 disclosures per 100 employees.
I wouldn't compare those figures directly. The datasets capture different populations, reporting channels and types of concerns. NAVEX also excludes organisations receiving fewer than 10 reports annually.
But they highlight why we need to understand what's actually being measured before drawing conclusions about the effectiveness of a reporting program.
There's no magic number of reports that proves you've got a healthy culture.
What matters is understanding what your numbers are telling you, and perhaps more importantly, what they're not.
An increase in reports isn't necessarily a bad thing
One of the things I've observed throughout my career is that when organisations make a genuine commitment to building a Speak Up culture, reporting volumes will often increase initially.
And that's not necessarily a sign that things are getting worse.
Think about what happens when you introduce a more accessible and independent reporting channel, promote it properly, train your people and demonstrate that concerns will be taken seriously.
People who previously stayed silent now have somewhere to go.
Some might raise concerns about recent incidents. Others may finally feel comfortable reporting something that's been happening for months, or even years.
The underlying problems may have existed all along.
What's changed is the organisation's ability to hear about them.
Consider an organisation with 1,000 employees that receives three reports one year and six the following year.
On paper, that's a 100% increase.
Sounds concerning, doesn't it?
But we're actually talking about three additional reports.
Before jumping to conclusions, I'd want to understand what those reports relate to, whether common themes are emerging, whether awareness of the program has improved and how the organisation responded.
A single serious allegation can be more significant than a dozen relatively minor matters. Equally, several seemingly unrelated complaints about the same leader, team or location could point to a much broader issue.
The same principle applies when reporting volumes decline.
Has the organisation genuinely improved? Are concerns being addressed through other channels? Or has something happened that's caused employees to lose confidence?
The trend matters. But the context matters more.
Are we making it too difficult for people to speak up?
There's another issue I think deserves more attention.
Many organisations still operate reporting programs built primarily around the concept of whistleblowing.
And while the legal protections are critically important, I wonder whether the way some programs are named and promoted unintentionally discourages employees from raising concerns.
Think about an employee who witnesses inappropriate behaviour, a potential conflict of interest or something that simply doesn't feel right.
If the reporting channel is called the Whistleblower Hotline, will they feel their concern is serious enough to report?
Or will they assume they need evidence of fraud, corruption or some other significant wrongdoing before they should use it?
We don't know how much this contributes to low reporting volumes. But based on my experience, I believe it's a barrier organisations should be examining.
I'm a strong advocate for broader Speak Up programs that encourage people to raise concerns early, rather than expecting employees to determine whether their issue meets a particular legal definition.
That assessment should be undertaken by appropriately trained professionals.
The objective isn't to generate more complaints for the sake of it.
It's to give organisations the opportunity to hear about problems before they become something more serious.
Your people are often your best early warning system
The importance of employee reporting is reinforced by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners' 2026 Report to the Nations.
The study examined 2,402 investigated occupational fraud cases and found that 43% were initially detected through tips.
Employees were responsible for 55% of those tips.
These findings aren't a benchmark for whistleblower reporting volumes. But they demonstrate the important role people can play in identifying issues that might otherwise go undetected.
I've seen this firsthand.
I recall an investigation involving a senior executive where concerns about their conduct had been known to people around them for some time.
But nobody felt comfortable coming forward.
It wasn't until a formal investigation commenced into other matters that someone finally felt confident enough to speak up.
What followed revealed a much broader pattern of misconduct than the organisation had initially identified.
That experience has stayed with me.
The information was there. People knew something wasn't right.
But the organisation wasn't hearing about it.
And that's the risk of assuming that silence means everything is fine.
Because the earlier an organisation becomes aware of a problem, the greater its opportunity to intervene before the consequences become more serious.
Prevention will always be better than your best response.
What should boards and executives be asking?
Rather than focusing exclusively on how many whistleblower reports were received during the quarter, I'd encourage boards and executives to take a broader view.
Do employees actually know where and how to raise concerns?
Do they feel safe doing so, particularly when the concern involves someone senior?
Are reporting channels accessible, independent where appropriate, and supported by regular communication and training?
And when someone does speak up, are we responding appropriately?
Are concerns being assessed, investigated and escalated where necessary? Are reporters being supported and protected? And are we addressing the underlying issues rather than simply closing cases?
I'd also encourage organisations to ask their employees directly whether they trust the reporting process.
A well-designed employee survey or Speak Up program health check can reveal things that a reporting dashboard never will.
Because an effective program isn't just about how many concerns are reported.
It's about whether people feel confident raising them, and whether the organisation has the capability and commitment to respond.
Silence shouldn't be mistaken for success
I'm not suggesting organisations should be trying to increase complaints.
Quite the opposite.
The goal should be to prevent misconduct wherever possible, identify concerns early and deal with them properly when they arise.
But we need to move away from the assumption that fewer reports automatically means a healthier culture.
An increase might be a warning sign. It might also indicate that people are finally starting to trust the process.
And zero reports might mean everything is going well.
Or it might mean there are serious issues that leadership simply isn't hearing about.
So the next time your board or executive team receives a report showing zero whistleblower disclosures, I'd encourage you not to simply move on to the next agenda item.
Instead, ask a more important question:
If someone in our organisation witnessed serious misconduct tomorrow, would they know how to speak up, would they feel safe doing so, and could we be confident we'd respond appropriately?
If you can't answer that with confidence, zero reports is probably the wrong thing to be celebrating.
About the author
Darren Murphy is the CEO and Founder of Core Integrity. With more than 25 years' experience across policing, corporate investigations and workplace integrity, including as a former NSW Police detective and former Head of Investigations at Commonwealth Bank, Darren works with organisations to build trusted Speak Up cultures, identify risks earlier and respond effectively when things go wrong.